Vessel, Sculpture and Other Fictions
This article was published in Ceramics Now on 27th March 2026.

Perhaps the vessel-versus-sculpture debate has never been settled because it was never a real question. This essay argues that it is a category mistake, the error Gilbert Ryle illustrated with a visitor who tours the colleges, libraries and playing fields of Oxford, then asks where the University is. “Vessel” and “sculpture” are not properties of clay. They are filing systems, built into Western museums, funding bodies and degree programmes over the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, and they rest on a dualist inheritance that other ceramic traditions never shared. The clay is indifferent: quartz inverts at 573°C whether the pot is bound for a museum or a kitchen table. The ceramicist is “materially monogamous, but institutionally promiscuous.”
The essay tests this against four artists. Peter Voulkos attacked the vessel to win the status of sculpture, and so confirmed the binary he meant to escape. Liu Jianhua’s gold-lustred pools of porcelain refuse to become vessels; read through Karen Barad’s intra-action, they record an encounter between porcelain, gravity and surface rather than a design imposed on matter. Takuro Kuwata’s bursting, glaze-flooded tea bowls, seen through Bill Brown’s Thing Theory, become material events. Before Magdalene Odundo’s burnished, body-like forms, the question falls away. The essay then turns to the author’s fortune cookie sculptures, which hold prophecies where a vessel would hold tea.
Barad’s framework extends to the museum label and critical vocabulary, which help produce the categories they claim merely to describe. The vessel did not die, the essay concludes; it became a quantum state, many things at once depending on the framework we view it through. That calls for a curatorial language that stops making objects pick a side. In Jingdezhen, where seventy-two trades once made a single object together, the question never arose. The essay wonders whether it ever needed to anywhere.
Full article can be read on the Ceramics Now website, here.
Image credit: Liu Jianhua, Square, 2012-2014, porcelain, steel, variable dimensions, exhibited at Square, Pace Beijing, Beijing, China in 2014. © Liujianhua Studio.