Back to Articles
provocationJune 26, 2026

The Index Cannot Be Archived

This student provocation was presented at the Permanence / Impermanence conference (London, 24-26 Jun 26) which I have huge gratitude to Clare Twomey, Pheobe Cummings and Tessa Peters for organising. I got to put faces to many of the names I had been researching and met many passionate artists, researchers and curators (too many to name!) and came out with my head spinning with ideas and inspiration. The conference was part of the three-year AHRC-funded research project, Future Ecologies of Clay. The research is being undertaken by the Ceramics Research Centre-UK, University of Westminster, in partnership with the Victoria and Albert Museum.

Phoebe Cummings, detail from Triumph of the Immaterial, (clay) Victoria & Albert Museum, 2017-18 Photo: Phoebe Cummings

Responding to the Future Ecologies of Clay project’s question of how museums might collect ephemeral, performative and participatory work, this provocation argues that the shortfall of documentation is semiotic and ontological rather than a matter of method or metadata. In Peirce’s terms, icons signify by resemblance, symbols by convention and indices by direct causal connection, and expanded-field clay practice is overwhelmingly indexical. Brie Ruais’s floor works record her body’s weight, Phoebe Cummings’s installations trace her hand and the slow work of gravity and humidity, and Clare Twomey’s Trophy is constituted by an audience taking it away.

Everything turns on one claim: an index cannot cross into another medium without becoming an icon. A photograph of a footprint resembles the footprint but was caused by light, not by the foot, so documentation does not preserve indexical works in degraded form; it produces icons of indices. Kendall Walton’s claim that photographs are transparent is granted as the strongest objection, yet it delivers vision only, not the body’s force, duration or material resistance, in a field where the visual is the least of what the work is. Sylvain Deleu’s photograph of Cummings’s dissolving fountain, Triumph of the Immaterial, is iconic of one moment, with no causal tie to the dissolving.

Documentation is a new artefact, standing alongside the work rather than replacing it, which fits Hanna Hölling’s account of artworks as sequences of states. The same distinction reconciles Rebecca Schneider’s claim that performance escapes the archive with Philip Auslander’s claim that documentation is performative: they describe different sign-relations folded into one word. The provocation closes by asking what institutions would do if they accepted that some works cannot be archived, only witnessed, and turned their attention to what they hold: related artefacts, witness records, artists’ writing, and documentation valued in its own right.

The official program of the event is published on arthist.net.

The website for the the Future Ecologies of Clay project can be accessed here.

Image credit: Phoebe Cummings, detail from Triumph of the Immaterial, (clay) Victoria & Albert Museum, 2017-18 Photo: Phoebe Cummings